Related Reviews
Fanfare
'This is an offbeat disc that will hardly duplicate anything in your collection.'
more >>
Classic FM (South Africa)
4 Stars
"...just relax and be transported to another world."
more >>
Adiemus Fan Magazine
"...it is rare to find an album that has been made by such a genuine and sincere attitude..."
more >>
American Recorder Magazine
"...lighthearted and engaging."
more >>
The Consort
"I highly commend this recording."
more >>
StereoMojo
"...this is one recording that is recommended to try."
more >>
Klassik.com
4 Stars
"...stellen ein feines und zugleich frisches Programm in einer eigenständigen Perspektive vor."
more >>
Fanfare
'Thorby is a thoroughly accomplished player...'
more >>
Toccata
"...seine wahre Pracht ist."
more >>
Atlanta Audio Society
"It's as delightful a way to spend an hour's listening as I know of."
more >>
MusicWeb-International
"This is a fascinating and most enjoyable recital of music..."
more >>
Opus Musica
"Este trabajo es un placer para los sentidos."
more >>
Hi-Fi Choice
5 Stars
An outstanding review for 'Garden of Early Delights'
more >>
Hi-Fi & Musik
'Hör du till dem som trodde att blockflöjt var enkelt att spela...'
more >>
Crescendo
4 Stars
"L’ensemble du programme baigne dans une séduction certaine faite de maîtrise technique..."
more >>
Gramophone
"This is Paradise indeed."
more >>
Home Theatre Hi-Fi
5 Stars
"...Thorby and Lawrence-King approach their virtuosic repertoire with consummate ease and joyful hearts."
more >>
Scotland on Sunday
4 Stars
"...there's no denying the quality of performance and works themselves."
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
"Thorby's playing exhibits a vitality, exuberance and earthiness..."
more >>
Early Music Review
"These are sparkling and fresh performances..."
more >>
Ultra Audio
"These works are played perfectly by Thorby and Andrew Lawrence-King..."
more >>
Classic FM Magazine
3 Stars
"...pleasant and original...sensitively accompanied."
more >>
High Fidelity
4½ Stars
A fantastic review from the Polish audiophile publication
more >>
The Irish Times
4 Stars
"...sheer joie-de-vivre..."
more >>
Classical Source
"Harp and recorder is an irresistible combination"
more >>
Bay Area Reporter
"...a delight."
more >>
International Record Review
"...a very captivating collection...her execution is flawless..."
more >>
Politiken (translated)
4 Stars
"Go in, close your eyes and let your ears open out: It is refreshingly chirpy, and it is good to listen to at all hours."
more >>
Politiken
4 Stars
"Det er vederkvægende kvidren - og der er nok af det til både tidlig og silde!"
more >>
The Telegraph
"No connoisseur of recorder-playing or Renaissance instrumental virtuosity will want to be without this delightful anthology."
more >>
Diario de Sevilla
"...las más espectaculares disminuciones se combinan con las dulces melodías."
more >>
Manchester Evening News
4 Stars
"The recorder playing is virtuosic in the extreme..."
more >>
The Scotsman
4 Stars
"Freshness and spontaneity light up every moment."
more >>
Financial Times
5 Stars
"...this is music to warm the heart and delight the senses."
more >>
Audiophile Audition
4 Stars
"...she navigates the speediest complex ornamentation with aplomb."
more >>

Garden of Early Delights - Pamela Thorby & Andrew Lawrence-King - Fanfare


01 November 2014
Fanfare
Barry Brenesal

Bosch's triptych The Garden of Earthly Delights may have been intended as a didactic warning against debauchery, as some commentators suggest, but its central panel's hedonism is so exuberant as to verge paradoxically on the innocent - and suggest a glad morning where all is delight, in a place where Time lounges at ease gazing fondly on a bottle of wine. Certainly the music on this album has no measure of Biblical invocation, wailing, and warning about sin in it. It's all music close to the ground, warm in folk tones, cheerful and melancholy by turns. These are the solo and duet instrumentals that evolved out of experiments in the 16th-century Italian states, drawing away from polyphony and closer to an expressive monody. Meanwhile, the ornamented possibilities allowed by divisions - literally dividing the line into shorter notes, a common practice among improvising folk musicians - became increasingly prominent. The results were showcases for display of tonal resources in slower works, agility and precision in faster ones.

The mix on this release is excellent. It includes both new works of the day and variations of older ones, and folk-inflected pieces that stray from the Netherlands to Italy, Spain, and England. Most are likely to be unfamiliar, but Fontana's Sonata seconda has shown up on disc more than once, and Schop's Lachrime Pavaen is a very clear homage to Dowland's Lachrimae or Seven Teares. Five works are performed by Andrew Lawrence-King along for tonal variety, while both Pamela Thorby and Lawrence-King can be heard together on the other eleven.

J.F. Weber reviewed this album upon its initial release, back in 2008 (Fanfare 32:3). He liked it, referring to Thorby as "a thoroughly accomplished player." I would only add that she deploys a bold fancy, creating the sense that at any moment the melodic line could, and sometimes will, take arbitrary flight. King in turn can be heard on double harp, arpa doppia (a triple harp, with three courses of strings, and psaltery. The sound is excellent: not a trace of mechanism, but clean and very close, with good balance between the instruments. In short, a delightful album.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Andrew Lawrence-KingAndrew Lawrence-King
Pamela ThorbyPamela Thorby
Garden of Early DelightsGarden of Early Delights