Related Reviews
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
'...for sheer freshness, insight and life-enhancing joy, this newcomer goes to the top of the class alongside Rachel Podger and Trevor Pinnock, Andrew Manze and Richard Egarr.'
more >>
The Sunday Times
' Russell's beautifully polished playing reveals an affecting relish for the music's searching expressivity, while Butt offers shapely, crisply articulated contributions...'
more >>
The Strad
The Strad Recommends: 'Intellectual challenge and a spirit of Empfindsamkeit animate these magnificent new recordings...'
more >>
Buxton Advertiser
'Yet the highlight of the concert was the two Bach sonatas for violin and harpsichord (BWV 1019 and BWV 1015): they really captured the symmetry and the lucidity of the composer. Their joint performance was sustaining and brilliant.'
more >>
Gramophone
'Refreshing...These are immensely likable performances...'
more >>
Brompton’s Fine & Rare Instruments
' And so it is therefore hardly surprising that such insight and integrity is to be found in the performance of specialists such as Russell and Butt.'
more >>
Artistxite
,,John Butts dynamisches, aber betont kontrapunktisches Cembalo und Lucy Russells flüssiges, vibrato-armes Spiel und der warme Klang ihrer Gagliano-Geige harmonieren dabei exzellent miteinander.''
more >>
Early Music Review
'Here Lucy Russell puts her own stamp on the works, giving a spirited and emotional rendering, and for that this recording is worth investing in.'
more >>
The Guardian
'This is playing rooted in bulletproof scholarship, but the scrunchiest harmonies and most roguish dance rhythms always win out.'
more >>

John Butt & Lucy Russell - J.S. Bach: Violin and Harpsichord Sonatas - BBC Radio 3 ‘CD Review’


23 May 2015
BBC Radio 3 ‘CD Review’
Andrew McGregor

If I tell you that I think this new Bach recording may excite a degree of critical controversy perhaps I might tell you why... it's from harpsichordist John Butt and violinist Lucy Russell, and while Butt is an acknowledged scholar and authority on Bach, his last recording from just a few months ago of the Well-Tempered Clavier excited some quite divergent reviews, not least here on CD Review. I confessed at the time that it left me cold - worse than that I didn't feel I understood his approach, his rubato etc.... but there were others who hailed Butt's Bach as a magnificent, probing account of the 48. Well, let's find out how the approach works in the accompanied violin sonatas. You will hear some of the same characteristics but at the same time I did find it easier to become involved this time, to share their view of Bach.

[Plays CD] 

I think it's fair to say I enjoyed it much more than I'd expected - the recorded sound is very good as well and it's my CD Review CD of the Week.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

John ButtJohn Butt
Lucy RussellLucy Russell
J.S. Bach: Sonatas for violin & harpsichordJ.S. Bach: Sonatas for violin & harpsichord