Related Reviews
Crescendo
4 Stars
« l'excellence de sa prononciation allemande jointe à une très fine sensibilité et à une remarquable diction soutenue par un souffle très bien conduit, un timbre clair, homogène nuancé jouant de facettes des plus ténues aux plus mordorées, donnent à ses enregistrements - à celui-ci notamment- une indéniable qualité, une richesse esthétique autant qu'émouvante. »
more >>
Classica
5 Stars
«Qui craindrait qu'Ann Murray soit un peu courte pour de telles ambitions se trompe : la voix est ambrée, patinée et chaude... son [Martineau] piano anime le propos et le modèle avec un sens architectonique incontestable.»
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
4 Stars
'Her Schumann selection begins with a touchingly delivered account of the Poems of Mary, Queen of Scots in which her artistic intelligence and commitment are as apparent as her skilful balance between words and notes.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
'This fine singer leaves us with an excellent last recording which is completely up to the high standards of her distinguished career.'
more >>
Diapson
« Murray touche par la sincérité de ses élans, sa générosité qui sied en particulier à Brahms. »
more >>
Pizzicato
,,Das sind gelebte und erfühlte Aufführungen, von denen man sich gerne unterhalten lässt.''
more >>
BBC Radio 3 'CD Review'
'...You heard Schumann's Poems of Mary Stuart, with which Ann Murray so memorably begins her valedictory recital with pianist Malcolm Martineau...If this is to be Ann Murray's farewell to us it's a lovely way to do it.'
more >>
Buffalo News
4 Stars
'This is a marvelous Lieder album.'
more >>
McAlister Matheson Music
‘beautifully sung’
more >>
SA-CD.net
5 Stars
'This is the kind of disc which justifies the whole art of German Lieder and will provide many happy hours of listening.'
more >>

Ann Murray - Brahms & Schumann: Lieder - American Record Guide


01 July 2015
American Record Guide
Erin Heisel

When I see these names on an album cover, I expect excellence; and indeed, here it is. Murray sounds as good as ever, and Martineau is sublime. The "supporting cast" is also good. The only odd thing about this program is that the title lists Brahms first, but the contents favor Schumann; in fact, there are only seven Brahms songs here, taking only about 15 minutes. As a huge Brahms fan, though perhaps more of the instrumental music than the songs, I was a little disappointed. Still, the Schumann songs and duets are beautiful and impeccably performed.

It's nice to hear Schumann's ‘Wilhelm Meister' songs performed as a group. The effect is decidedly dramatic, and I hope this will inspire more performances of the songs this way. Duets and two other songs fill out the extended Schumann portion of the program. Of particular interest to me was the intimate and exquisitely performed duet ‘So Wahr die Sonne Scheinet'.

The Brahms songs, all sung by Murray, are simply spectacular. They are mainly "greatest hits": ‘Dein Blaues Auge',‘Meine Liebe Ist Grün' (here by the alternate title, ‘Junge Liebe I'), and ‘Ständchen' (Kugler setting), to name a few.

A fabulous program and worthy addition to your lieder collection. Excellent notes by Susan Youens. 


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Ann MurrayAnn Murray
Malcolm MartineauMalcolm Martineau
Brahms & Schumann: LiederBrahms & Schumann: Lieder