Related Reviews
Kultur Port
'Clear, transparent, and not just for the Christmas holidays.'
more >>
Concerto
Oratorio: „Das ergibt insgesamt einen entspannten, bassbetonten und doch transparenten Ensembleklang mit einem ungewohnt strahlenden Hör­nerklang...Alle singen und spielen mit großer Ausstrahlung... etwa die liebevoll vokal-in­strumental aufgefächerte Rhetorik in den Chören der Engel, Hirten und Weisen.'' / Magnificat: „Überhaupt präsentiert sich die Aufnahme in einem warmen, abgerundeten Klangbild''
more >>
KMT
”Helt naturligt blev den nyligen släppta friskt glänsande inspelningen...strålande solistprestationer som i Juloratoriet i en ljuvlig återgivning av Juldagens.”
more >>
Fanfare
'The Magnificat is equally magnificent.'
more >>
Early Music Today
5 Stars
Editor's Choice: 'Rarely, very rarely, a recording comes along that because of its content and level of performance seems to be hors concours. This is just such a recording.'
more >>
Iowa Public Radio
2015 Classical Mega-Meta-List: 'It is also the joyous-Bach-Christmas CD of the year. And the performances are so special that even if you already own many recordings of the Magnificat or the Cantata you should hear it.'
more >>
The Herald Scotland
Top 10 Scottish Classical Albums of 2015: #1 spot
more >>
Europadisc
Europadisc 2015 Disc of the Year: 'In the end it was the Dunedin Consort's recording of Bach's Magnificat that gripped us most, not just for its combination of brilliant musicianship and fastidious research, but because the reconstruction as a whole proves such an involving, immersive experience for the listener.'
more >>
BBC Radio 3 ‘CD Review’
'A Bach recording that's going to make the air vibrate with joy...a splendid recording.'
more >>
The Sunday Times
'His quintet of soloists are brilliant illusionists, sounding like a crowd in Omnes generationes.'
more >>
The Arts Desk
'This disc's academic credentials are impeccable, but my reasons for loving it are purely musical; John Butt's Bach programme allows us to party as if it was, er, 1723...Essential listening.'
more >>
Sydsvenskan
'John Butt gör en finkänslig och rörlig rekonstruktion av J S Bachs magnifika vesper.'
more >>
Classical MPR
'The effect is reverent and seamless. The musicianship of the singers and the players is flawless, and it's interesting to hear the works in their historical context.'
more >>
Pizzicato
Supersonic Award: ,,Den Aufnahmetechnikern ist ein Meisterstück gelungen...Unser Tipp für die Feiertage!''
more >>
The Herald Scotland
Top 20 Classical Recordings for 2015: 'Hard to imagine a classier Christmas album.'
more >>
YLE Klassinen
'Sekä Magnificat että joulukantaatti ovat säihkyvän jouluisia teoksia, joissa trumpetit raikaavat ja patarummut jylisevät. Toki sijansa saa myös hempeä joulutunteilu.'
more >>
Iowa Public Radio
Flavorful Picks from 2015: 'Linn's recorded sound is rich, glowing, natural, and clear.'
more >>
Ouverture - Das Klassik-Blog
'...I have rarely heard the Magnificat so impressively performed...'
more >>
Financial Times
5 Stars
'It is a brilliant deal: 21st-century listeners get all of Bach's glorious music associated with December 25 1723, performed with zest and imagination, without having to sit through the sermon.'
more >>
Gramophone
Editor's Choice: 'Another intriguing and excellently performed project from Butt and his Dunedin Consort: a delightful recreation of what Bach’s first Christmas in Leipzig might well have sounded like.'
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
Choral & Song Choice: 'What follows is a holistically conceived, beautifully paced, exhilaratingly executed performance.'
more >>
Rondo Magazine
5 Stars
,,Unter diesen Bedingungen kann auch das bekannte Magnificat in seiner gleißend hellen Es-Dur-Fassung nur eine Freude sein – diese Erwartung bestätigt sich beim Hören: Das ist sehr, sehr wohltuend.''
more >>
BBC Radio Scotland ‘Classics Unwrapped’
'It’s a magnificent recording…a hearty congratulations on a truly hearty disc. I really, really loved listening to that.'
more >>
BBC Radio 3 ‘In Tune’
'It’s wondrous music.'
more >>
Artistxite
,,Die Illusion funktioniert: Man fühlt sich unmittelbar in die besondere Stimmung einer festlichen Vesper hineinversetzt. Butt und sein Ensemble erweisen sich (zum wiederholten Male) als akkurate Spurensucher, die die Unmittelbarkeit des historischen Kontexts für den heutigen Hörer wieder erfahrbar machen.''
more >>
Classical CD Choice
'Quite possibly the most persuasive version of Bach's Magnificat you are likely to hear in modern times.'
more >>
PS Audio
Classical Gifts of 2015: 'Hands down, my first choice this year...'
more >>
Sinfini Music
5 Stars
Best Choral Album: 'Andrew Stewart has heard no finer disc this year than John Butt and the Dunedin Consort's new recording of Bach's Magnificat and Christmas Cantata BWV 63, filled with insight and energy.'
more >>
Andrew Everard
'standout'
more >>
Merry and Bright Blog
'an excellent record'
more >>
Early Music Review
'...what is a very good example of John Butt's marriage between arresting scholarship, enormous musicality - the tempi are so naturally right - and pragmatic skills: conceiving and bringing such a complex production to fruition is a huge task, and the whole disc is so coherently musical from the word go. Give it to all your friends for Christmas: this is contextual Bach at its very best.'
more >>
The Irish Times
4 Stars
'The scene is set for music-making that's lucid and festive, captured in sound that's both intimate and full. A spirited Christmas celebration with a difference.'
more >>
Classic FM 'Chart'
'superb'
more >>
BBC Radio 3 'CD Review'
Disc of the Week: '...director John Butt reconstructs for us the kind of sounds you might have heard when Bach celebrated his first Christmas day vespers in Leipzig in 1723…It’s an absolute joy.'
more >>
The Scotsman
5 Stars
'...yet another astonishing triumph...the musicianship is exquisite; the emotional impact is immediate. This is world class.'
more >>
Europadisc
'Butt and his musicians combine an earthy exuberance with some beautifully sensitive and ethereal singing and playing...this is an enormously satisfying and enjoyable disc, reinforcing yet again the Dunedin Consort's enviable reputation in this repertoire.'
more >>
The Observer
5 Stars
'Another bull's-eye hit from John Butt's Dunedin Consort...brilliantly done.'
more >>
HR Audio
5 Stars
'In all respects this is one of the most enjoyable releases that I have encountered this year and cannot recommend too highly.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
Recording of the Month: 'This is one of the most enjoyable and stimulating Bach discs to have come my way...The performance standards are uniformly excellent and the music is life-enhancing.'
more >>
McAlister Matheson Music
'Look no further for this year’s essential Christmas disc!'
more >>
AllMusic
'The music is splendidly recorded at Greyfriars Kirk in Edinburgh, and the end result is a Bach performance that is original in concept and satisfying in details.'
more >>

Dunedin Consort - J.S. Bach: Magnificat - MusicWeb International


23 November 2015
MusicWeb International
Brian Wilson

The headline news is that, though I have many other very fine recordings of the two major works, Cantata No.63 and the E-flat version of the Magnificat with the Christmas interpolations, this new recording just about outdoes them all.

This is not the first of John Butt's Bach recordings to be reconstructions of actual liturgical celebrations that might have occurred during his time in Leipzig: in this case we have a credible reconstruction of his first Christmas Vespers in the Nikolaikirche in 1723.  

I'm not going to renege on my recommendation of the Herreweghe, but John Butt has gone one further and created a sense of occasion by opening with a Gabrieli motet and interpolating appropriate organ preludes and congregational hymns.  With a CD filled almost to bursting, a few items have had to be left out, but these can be downloaded free from Linn: the organ prelude Der Tag der ist so freudenreich, BWV650, the congregational pulpit hymn Ein Kindelein so loebelich and the final collect, responsory and blessing.  It's a bit fiddly to insert these tracks in the right place - perhaps Hyperion could have included them with the download.  I put them into a sub-folder labelled ‘bonus tracks' and Winamp read them as tracks 31-34, after the main tracks 1-30.  If you download the ‘digital de luxe' version from Linn the tracks are in the right places. 

The opening work, an 8-part motet by Giovanni Gabrieli, is included in a North German collection of the time: it would have been sung by the very best singers from the Thomasschule, though it seems unlikely that they would have been as accomplished as the team on the new recording - the five named soloists plus Katie Schofield, Malcolm Bennett and Dominic Barberi, with organ, cello and violone accompaniment, who get the album off to a flying start. 

The organ pieces are just as welcome as the vocal works.  It was as a performer of Bach's organ music on the Harmonia Mundi label that John Butt first came to my attention: his recording of the Schübler Chorales and preludes and fugues on and of the Trio Sonatas. 

The first organ piece here, the Prelude BWV600, from Orgel-büchlein, is well up to the standard of those earlier recordings and the Greyfriars organ, restored in 1990, makes a good baroque sound.  The booklet lists this as Gott, durch deine Güte, but it's also known as Gottes Sohn ist kommen, which is more appropriate to Christmas, and the download track carries the latter title.  Nor are the remaining organ pieces any less well performed.  As John Butt notes in the booklet these preludes were intended not to be played one after the other in a 70-minute CD programme, as we normally hear them now, but to set the mood for a following choral work. 

I've heard some very fine recordings of Cantata No.63 but this knocked me off my perch from the start, capturing the joyful spirit of the work more than any other that I know.  Bach brought this cantata with him from Weimar and it may have seemed a little too exuberant for the staid burghers of Leipzig.  A good performance should have had the congregation dancing in the aisles - the text exhorts them to join the round dance: Kommt, ihr Christen, kommt zur Reihen.  Butt's interpretation might have tempted them to climb up the organ loft but such was not the staid Lutheran way in Bach's day, despite Martin Luther's own love of joyful music and his expectation of joining the Reihe(round dance) in Heaven. 

The performance of the Magnificat has the same dancing qualities as the Cantata, though it's the latter that really persuaded me to make this a Recording of the Month.  You may not wish to have the Christmas interpolations all year round, so they have been separately tracked.  That's fine if you can be bothered to programme them out but I prefer to keep them.  The practice of interpolating other music in the Magnificat at Christmas, in Latin and German, had been common for some time before Bach: Hieronymus Prætorius's Magnificat Quinti toni, which features on a very fine recent recording, interpolates a number of extra verses: Joseph, lieber JosephOmnes nunc conciteHodie apparuit and, verse by verse, In dulci jubilo.  (A Wondrous Mystery: Stile Antico, Harmonia Mundi HMU807575). 

I listened to the recording as a 24/96 download and the sound is every bit as impressive as the performances.  Past experience of comparing 24-bit Linn downloads and their SACD equivalents suggests that it's equivalent to the HD stereo layer of the disc.  

The notes in the booklet are extremely valuable, especially in setting the music in liturgical context and in arguing the case for the use of the older Tief-Kammerton or ‘French pitch', approx. A=392, for strings and woodwind, thus allowing the trumpets to perform in the higher ‘baroque pitch'Kammerton or Cammerton of 415 in their native key of D, as they do in the other version of theMagnificat in D.  D at the higher pitch = E-flat at the lower.  Those seeking further elucidation will find a helpful article on this complex subject in the Oxford Companion to Music (Pitch, 3). 

Even if you have another recording of either, or even both, of the main works you will be bowled over by this new recording.  It's top of my Christmas 2015 list so far and I expect it to remain so. 
Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Dunedin ConsortDunedin Consort
John ButtJohn Butt
J.S. Bach: Magnificat & Christmas CantataJ.S. Bach: Magnificat & Christmas Cantata
J.S. Bach: Magnificat & Christmas Cantata (Digital Deluxe Version)J.S. Bach: Magnificat & Christmas Cantata (Digital Deluxe Version)