Related Reviews
MusicWeb International
'This is lieder singing in the highest division! The twelve songs that constitute this cycle...may not have been more beautifully sung in recent times.'
more >>
Das Opernglas
'One does not know what one should admire more about Boesch's interpretation, the extremely beautiful, velvety voice, his subtle interpretation of every word, the ever-natural-sounding singing or his ability to reach the heart of a song...'
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
'Boesch's flexible and rich-grained baritone blends with the colourful support of Malcolm Martineau at the piano to offer splendidly characterised accounts...'
more >>
'The interpretations are intriguingly evocative and I cannot remember hearing Mahler's ‘Lieder eines Fahrenden Gesellen’ this atmospheric.'
more >>
Opera Lounge
'These cycles are indispensable...'
more >>
La Libre Belgique
' exemplary recording due to its poetic, vocal and musical unity...Boesch's voice - powerful, full-bodied...[is] supported on the piano by the brilliant Martineau.'
more >>
CD of the Week: 'Florian Boesch, and the outstanding pianist Malcolm Martineau, use Mahler's piano version to re-interpret the songs in the most refined and precise manner.'
more >>
BBC Radio 3 'Record Review'
'...the way he goes from the virile nightly dialogue of “Waldesgesprach” so well characterised to the nocturnal hush and unearthly stillness of “Mondnacht” is extraordinary.'
more >>
The Arts Desk
4 Stars
'Boesch has a tone and a mode of delivery for every mood.'
more >>
Opera Today
'...their Mahler Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen takes excellence to even greater levels.'
more >>
Classical Iconoclast
'Although I've heard dozens of performances over the last 40 years, this took my breath away.'
more >>
'The profound sense of leave-taking in the final Wayfarer song draws some of the most coloristically subtle singing I’ve yet heard from Boesch.'
more >>
The Sunday Times
'Florian Boesch sings with his usual subtlety...He's splendid in the Goethe songs, and in the Mahler...'
more >>

Florian Boesch - Schumann & Mahler: Lieder - Audiophile Sound

27 October 2017
Audiophile Sound
Rob Pennock
5 Stars

Performance: 5

Given that Florian Boesch and Malcolm Martineau are two of the hottest lieder tickets in town it seems odd that this recital has taken almost exactly three years to appear having been recorded in November 2014 and it is also rather strange that any record label should think it acceptable to offer a programme lasting a mere 47 minutes. In terms of the quality of singing, as ever Boesch deploys an exceptionally large range of tonal and dynamic shading and as with his recent Hyperion Winterreise he appears to be in conversation with the listener, which makes these sound like live performances. As with so much of Schumann’s output Liederkreis consists of a series of short songs and in the first Boesch creates a beautifully moulded melodic line, in the more demonstrative Intermezzo his tone is powerfully focused, he dances his way through Waldesgespräch, spins an ultra-refined web of pianissimo sound in Die Stille and Martineau is equally eloquent, so this is an equal partnership not an accompaniment. And so it goes on, without any sense of artifice both artists highlight key words and phrases and bring the cycle to an extrovert end in Frühlingsnacht. In the Op. 98a songs one notes the richness of Boesch’s lower register and depth of feeling evinced in these late works. Mahler’s multi-faceted lieder make exceptional demands of any singer and you would have to go back to Janet Baker and Geoffrey Parsons (Hyperion, 1983) to hear the equal of these performances, where there is a sense of rapt concentration, acute emotional involvement and some of the most ravishing sounds you are ever likely to hear from a baritone. So great singing and playing, but pity about the playing time.

Balance: 5
Inner balance: 3
Detail and clarity: 5
Dynamic range: 4

Sound-wise Linn chose Crear, a remote Scottish coastal venue that uses – amongst other things - a highly thought of bespoke wedding reception service to subsidises its arts work. Pictures of the premises show a long, narrow, high roofed hall that is still quite compact, but has far too much glass for a concert-hall, so it came as no surprise to hear that the reverberation time is too long for a lieder recital (the Wigmore Hall has a reverb time of only about 2 seconds) which means that Florian Boesch does have a tendency, especially in forte passages, to float somewhere in the middle of the image as opposed to being slightly in front of the piano. This is a pity because the piano is ideally balanced just to the rear of the speakers and as this 24bit, 192kHz sound the exceptionally wide tonal range and unique timbre of both players is very well presented. The dynamic range is also extended so you can hear all of Boesch’s variation from pppp to fff, there is plenty of presence and projection and is now usually the case no register is given undue prominence. Much to Linn’s credit, like Hyperion they have their own highly efficient download application, which further adds to the desirability of this release.

Bookmark and Share

Related Links

Florian BoeschFlorian Boesch
Malcolm MartineauMalcolm Martineau
Schumann & Mahler: LiederSchumann & Mahler: Lieder