Related Reviews
Teaxs Classical Review
'Her remarkable control of the very softest dynamics was breathtaking.'
more >>
Crescendo
4½ Stars
« Avec le Scottish Chamber Orchestra, Ingrid Fliter et Antonio Mendez nous emmènent dans une interprétation chambriste, associant volontiers luminosité, grâce et délicatesse. La virtuosité sans failles de la pianiste est au service du matériau sonore et des nombreuses dynamiques. » / 'With the Scottish Chamber Orchestra, Ingrid Fliter and Antonio Mendez capture a chamber interpretation which combines luminosity, grace and delicacy. The flawless virtuosity of the the pianist is at the service of the sound material and its many dynamics.'
more >>
Piano
5 Stars
'Das ist eine wirklich grandiose Einspielung!'
more >>
American Record Guide
'I find it very mature, extremely beautiful, and expressive...'
more >>
Audiophile Audition
5 Stars
'...Ingrid Fliter's performance can hold its own among the best I've heard.'
more >>
MDR Kultur
'...on the one hand deep-rooted, introverted, romantic melody in the lyrical melodic, on the other hand tense, forced, playful virtuosity rather clear cut.'
more >>
Irish Times
4 Stars
'There's something really invigorating about Argentinian pianist Ingrid Fliter's approach to these two staples of the 19th-century romantic piano repertoire.'
more >>
Pizzicato
5 Stars
„Halte ich dies für ein hervorragende Einspielung des Klavierkonzerts op. 54.“
more >>
BBC Radio 3 ‘Record Review’
Disc of the Week: 'What really works for me is the Mendelssohn G minor Concerto with Fliter exchanging the prettiness of some performances for a more dynamic interpretation. And glittering finger-work that attracts some equally sparkling responses from the Scottish Chamber Orchestra. Lovely choices of tempo, the whole thing beautifully balanced.'
more >>
The Telegraph
5 Stars
'Fliter has the measure of the [Mendelssohn concerto]. The first movement has real fire; the finale bears a cheerful smile and sizzles with vitality; and the central, song-without-words, Andante, is played with heart-stopping tenderness and warmth.'
more >>
Gramophone
'The Mendelssohn concerto suits Fliter particularly well, and she’s alive to the impetuosity of the outer movements, as well as to the work’s more poetic elements. Fliter’s command of the drama is second to none…She seizes the music by the scruff of the neck.'
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
4 Stars
'There's still room for something fresh to be said with this evergreen music…in both the Mendelssohn and Schumann, Fliter plays with tautness and energy, fitting hand-in-glove with the smaller chamber-orchestra forces of the SCO and drier recorded sound. Heartfelt and intelligent, this is life-enhancing music, and as a bonus there's The Fair Melusina Overture.'
more >>
Ming Pao Weekly
'full of energy' (review in Chinese)
more >>
Classic FM
Drive Discovery: 'The wait was worth it. She brilliantly tackles Schumann's shifting colours and technical demands head on, not for a moment compromising the work's lyricism. And she brings out all of Mendelssohn's melodic genius while deftly handling all of the work's demands on the virtuoso.'
more >>
Politiken
4 Stars
'albummet stærkt anbefales' / 'highly recommended'
more >>

Ingrid Fliter & SCO - Schumann & Mendelssohn: Piano Concertos - AllMusic


01 April 2016
AllMusic
James Manheim
4½ Stars

In the latter decades of the 19th century the program offered on this release might have been one of the most common of all for an evening of piano-and-orchestra music. Nowadays the Piano Concerto No. 1 in G minor, Op. 25, of Mendelssohn is not the repertory giant it once was, but it's a beautiful fit with the expressive world of pianist Ingrid Fliter. Several factors combine to make this an unusually satisfying Romantic piano concerto offering, but among them is the high-contrast approach of Fliter herself, really capturing the listener's attention. And it's all done within the moderate parameters of the Scottish Chamber Orchestra under the young conductor Antonio Méndez, the same size as the orchestra that would have played these works in the composers' own time. The Schumann Piano Concerto in A minor, Op. 54, contains an episodic feel in Fliter's hands, all within the concerto's intricate form: the opening is strikingly urgent without being loud, the lyrical passages seem to bloom, and the finale broadens out nobly. The Mendelssohn is even more episodic, and here Fliter captures, as few others have, the formally free quality of the work, which inspired listeners of the time to propose elaborate programs for it. Mendelssohn himself called these programs "stupid," but they did capture something of what made the concerto fresh when Mendelssohn wrote it, and Fliter restores that freshness. Throw in close attention to small detail from all the performers and fine transparent sound from Linn's engineers, working at the RSNO Center's Royal Concert Hall in Glasgow, and you have a standout recording.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Antonio MendezAntonio Mendez
Ingrid FliterIngrid Fliter
Scottish Chamber OrchestraScottish Chamber Orchestra
Schumann & Mendelssohn Piano ConcertosSchumann & Mendelssohn Piano Concertos
Schumann & Mendelssohn Piano ConcertosSchumann & Mendelssohn Piano Concertos
Schumann: Piano Concerto in A minor LPSchumann: Piano Concerto in A minor LP