Related Reviews
BBC Music Magazine
4 Stars
'For a start, these pieces are so irresistibly tuneful, and then there's the humour - less suave, sometimes edgier than Mozart's, but at times winningly delicate.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
'In every way these are exemplary performances in clear, close, but warm sound of some of Beethoven’s lighter music, which warrant an enthusiastic recommendation from me.'
more >>
Gramophone
'The Sextet, too, is marvellously done here – fluent, articulate and sensitively shaped, with delicious interleaving of phrases in the rambunctious finale.'
more >>
Pizzicato
'... a lot of freshness, vitality and color.'
more >>
The Scotsman
5 Stars
'...a showstopper, where the very stuff of theatre – its tensions and releases, its compelling narrative vitality and emotional nuances – is played out in scintillating musical terms.'
more >>
Terzwerk
'The musicians not only impress individually, but also harmonize as an ensemble.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
'You couldn’t hope for more masterful, affable guides.'
more >>
Financial Times
4 Stars
'The wind soloists of the Scottish Chamber Orchestra make a lovely job of them and throw in a handful of pleasing miniatures to fill the disc.'
more >>
BBC Radio 3 ‘Record Review’
'All the wit and character of all the individual players coming through but yet still at the service of the whole ensemble. Something close to a perfect balance of individuality and team spirit.'
more >>
The Wee Review
4 Stars
'The wind soloists of the SCO demonstrate why they are Scotland’s, and indeed one of Britain’s, finest chamber ensembles.'
more >>

SCO Winds - Beethoven: Music for Winds - The Herald


03 March 2018
The Herald
Keith Bruce

The Scottish Chamber Orchestra currently boasts star players across the strings as well, but even in years when it has coped with long-standing vacancies on the front desks in those sections, its winds have always been of note. Nonetheless the line-up on this recording is particularly impressive, and of those only bassoonist Peter Whelan – increasingly in demand as a conductor as well as a soloist and leader of his Ensemble Marsyas – has departed since it was made.

Launched with a live broadcast from London’s Wigmore Hall on Monday February 12, this album ranges from Beethoven’s early Octet to the duo for Whelan and clarinettist Maximiliano Martin from the same years, but possibly not by the composer at all. The contemporary E flat Rondino is the only other work to include the oboes of Robin Williams and Rosie Staniforth with a sextet of horns, bassoons and clarinets opening and closing the disc, playing music from later in the 1790s.

All three of Scotland’s orchestras currently boast principal horn players of the first rank, but it is the SCO’s Alec Frank-Gemmill, a BBC New Generation Artist, who probably currently has the highest UK profile in broadcasts and recordings. This album is a reminder that he (and Whelan until recently) are playing in very fine company indeed at the SCO.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Alec Frank-GemmillAlec Frank-Gemmill
Ludwig van BeethovenLudwig van Beethoven
Maximiliano MartinMaximiliano Martin
Peter WhelanPeter Whelan
Scottish Chamber OrchestraScottish Chamber Orchestra
Beethoven: Music for WindsBeethoven: Music for Winds