Related Reviews
The Consort
'...it feels like a live performance.'
more >>
Audiophile Audition
Chosen as 'Best of the Year Discs for 2011'
more >>
6moons.com
Blue Moon Award: 'It's excellent from start to finish with amazing young singers...'
more >>
Opera
Disc of the Month: '...artistry of the highest quality.'
more >>
Early Music Review
'...we owe a great debt to conductor Ian Page for bringing [Artaxerxes] back to life. '
more >>
Opera Now
5 Stars
Opera Now Choice: 'The orchestra has a natural sheen and the voices - especially those of the women - are radiant.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
"Anyone with an interest in 18th century opera ought to try the disc. They won't be disappointed."
more >>
Gramophone
"Brilliant tone of Elizabeth Watts...[and] admirable work by all the other voices"
more >>
Gramophone - Super Audio Corner
"The performance is thrilling, with exemplary singing and playing..."
more >>
Audiophile Audition
5 Stars
"I can't recommend this release too highly. It should be in the collection of every opera lover."
more >>
Classic FM
4 Stars
'The recitatives...are delivered with conviction, flowing seamlessly into the arias.'
more >>
6Moon.com
Blue Moon Award: "The orchestra is spectacular...Linn's studio recording is as usual excellent...Enjoy!"
more >>
The Scotsman
4 Stars
"[A] classy, crystal clear recording."
more >>
International Record Review
'admirable set'
more >>
Pizzicato
"...est rendu dans une lecture vivante, avec d'excellents chanteurs..."
more >>
The Observer
"Elizabeth Watts and Rebecca Bottone shine under Ian Page's crisp direction."
more >>
North London News
"...the singing is both intensely musical and full of acute psychological nuance..."
more >>
The Sunday Times
"Christopher Ainslie is outstanding in the title role."
more >>
SA-CD.net
5 Stars
"I cannot recommend this too strongly...this is truly a set to banish the wintry gloom!"
more >>

Classical Opera Company - Artaxerxes - BBC Music Magazine


01 March 2011
BBC Music Magazine
George Hall
5 Stars

One of the biggest throws of the career of the 18th-century English theatre composer Thomas Arne (1710-78), Artaxerxes remained a success at Covent Garden and elsewhere from its premiere in 1762 up to the late 1830s.  It even survived on the stage, in partially rewritten form, following the disastrous fire that ripped through the Theatre Royal in 1808, destroying its only complete score and performance materials; fortunately, by then the bulk of the opera had been published in full score, leaving just the recitatives and ensemble finale missing.  Here, conductor Ian Page and musicologist Duncan Druce have filled these respective gaps, matching Arne's style so convincingly that you would never notice the joins.

Arne could be a good composer - it's with good reason that his 'Rule, Britannia!' is still popular - but he was less than a genius.  Artaxerxes was his attempt to write an English-language opera modelled on Italian opera seria; Arne himself seems to have prepared the translation of the libretto by Metastasio, the leading practitioner of the genre in his day.  Artaxerxes contains some good ideas amidst others that are merely generic and a few that are empty.  But at its best, as in the soprano showpiece, 'The soldier tir'd' (a favourite of Victorian singers, latterly recorded by Joan Sutherland) it's very worthwhile; here in this recording that aria is resplendently delivered by Elizabeth Watts.

Artaxerxes' variable musical quality will probably prevent it from resuimg a regular place in the operatic repertory, but here it is presented complete and to a consistently high standard.  The very fine cast enters with spirit into the text's convoluted scenario of love and betrayal in ancient Persia and delivering the notes with assurance.  Ian Page conducts the period-instrument forces with conviction, and the sound is excellent.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Classical OperaClassical Opera
ArtaxerxesArtaxerxes