Related Reviews
Herald Scotland
'...rewarding...'
more >>
Ionarts
'...historically most informed... in an infectious, tight performance...'
more >>
Opera News
'One of the most thought-provoking recordings of the past few years, and ultimately one of the most fulfilling.'
more >>
International Record Review
'All of the soloists are generally outstanding. Nicholas Mulroy’s lithe, sensitive Evangelist is the epitome of narrative clarity and contrasts beautifully with the calming, authoritative richness of Matthew Brook’s Jesus.'
more >>
Scherzo
'La dirección de Butt se nota asimismo de una minuciosidad extrema, en lo cual recibe la inestimable ayuda de unas tomas de amplia atmósfera y en el punto justo de reverberación para que la calidez de los mensajes lleguen sin un ápice de articio'
more >>
Classical.net
'Contrast has made for real impact'
more >>
MusicWeb International
Recording of the Month: 'I will not be surprised if this recording of the St. John Passion comes to be regarded as a landmark in the work's already distinguished discography.'
more >>
voix-des-arts.blogspot.co.uk
'The Dunedin Consort prove themselves to be instrumentalists of extraordinary ability.'
more >>
Early Music Review
'This is far and away the most musical and satisfying performance around among the many, many versions available.'
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
Recording of the Month: 'a dramatic, profoundly considered reading.'
more >>
Early Music Review
'Whatever St John Passion you own, buy this one - it's unique!'
more >>
Sunday Times
'Linn offers a fascinating extra dimension.'
more >>
Irish Times
'the performance is nimble on its feet.'
more >>
The Observer
'Historic and supremely important'
more >>
Audiophile Audition
'The performance is a fine one, even exceptional'
more >>
Financial Times
'wonderfully pure, buoyant and transparent.'
more >>
Herald Scotland
4 Stars
Live Review from Kelvingrove Museum, Glasgow
more >>
The Guardian
4 Stars
Live Review from Kelvingrove Museum, Glasgow
more >>
The Times
'the liturgical experience offers benefits to heart and mind'
more >>
MusicWeb International
Recording of the Month: 'an exceptionally fine small-scale performance'
more >>
The Herald
'A breakthrough on Bach's John Passion'
more >>
The Big Issue
'The impact is huge. The architecture, emotion and implication of Bach's music all change.'
more >>
McAlister Matheson Music
'This Johannes Passion performance is without doubt the most involving and dramatic I have encountered.'
more >>
Gramophone
Recording of the Month: '...[a] perfectly paced ensemble Passion'
more >>
Gramophone
'As the Dunedin Consort record Bach's St John Passion in the context of a Good Friday vespers, David Vickers speaks to John Butt and others about the rewards of liturgical reconstruction.'
more >>

John Passion - Dunedin Consort - SA-CD.net


16 March 2013
SA-CD.net
Polly Nomial
5 Stars

A Passion with a difference - all to our good.

Somewhat unusually for one of Bach's great choral works, the Johannes-Passion is rather thin on the ground as far as SACD goes. My library version until now was Bach: St. John Passion - Netherlands Bach Society but this surpasses it for musical intensity and the imaginative presentation of the the work. John Butt presents this work as part of a service, opening with Bach's Chorale Prelude "Da Jesus an dem Kreuze Stund". This is then followed by Schein's Congregational Chorale of the same title before an extract from Buxtehude's Organ Prelude to the Passion leads gloriously into Part One of Bach's work.

It is immediately apparent when comparing the van Veldhoven release that Butt inspires another layer of spiritual intensity; the forces are the same size and are as follows:
Nicholas Mulroy (Evangelista & Tenor Concertist)
Matthew Brook (Jesus & Bass Concertist)
Robert Davies (Petrus & Pilatus)
Stephen Chambers (Servus)
Joanne Lunn (Ancilla & Soprano Concertist)
Clare Wilkinson (Alto Concertist)
Katie Trethewey (Soprano Ripienist)
Alexandra Gibson (Alto Ripienist)
Malcolm Bennett (Tenor Ripienist)
Christopher Borrett (Bass Ripienist)

The power of expression in "Herr, unser Herrscher" is almost unbearable from the strings that nag away to the pained counterpoint in the chorus - the devotion is almost painful and, if one didn't now different, this would make one question if Bach had in fact composed an opera. This comes ever more prominently to mind with the expert pacing and phrasing (at both the levels of musical sentence and paragraph).

As before in Butt's recordings of Bach's work, no detail is left unattended and the way the short choral chorales take on a pivotal role in the drama is indicative of his approach. The singers from Jesus upwards (in a notational sense) respond with equal regard and audibly give their all to recitatives and aria's alike. At the end of Part One, Butt performs Bach's Chorale Prelude "O Lamm Gottes unschuldig" and, as before, the University of Glasgow Chapel Choir under James Grossmith sing Schein's Congregational Chorale of the same name. At this point of the service, one can turn to http://www.linnrecords.com/recording-j-s--bach--john-passion--sermon-section.aspx for a free download of a suitable sermon & intercession (this is not present on the SACD's) from the Sermon Section within The Leipzig Service of Vespers for Good Friday (German language). There are also two tracks, one each from John Butt & Robin Holloway, offering their thoughts on the John Passion.

Part Two is preceded by Bach's Chorale Prelude "Christus, der uns selig macht"; both this Chorale Prelude and up to & including the tenor aria "Erwäge, wie sein blutgefärbter Rücken" are also on disc one, causing a split. This is the one downside of setting Bach's masterpiece as if in the middle of a church service. Fortunately, one needs would normally expect some moments of repose after such an aria so it is not of much consequence in terms of breaking the spell of the drama.

At the conclusion of Part Two, we are offered Jacob Handl Gallus' "Ecce quomodo moritur", the Responsary, Collect, Blessing from the Leipzig service and Schein's "Gott sei uns gnädig und barmherzig" (UoGCC/Grossmith) before, as in the opening of this liturgical event, Butt plays Bach's Chorale Prelude "Nun danket alle Gott" with Schein's Congregational Chorale rounding off the proceedings with a pleasing sense of organisational symmetry. I would normally highlight the contribution of one or more singers, players but it would be unfair to do so - every last one is deserving of the same praise.

The recording, made in the Greyfriar's Kirk (Edinburgh), is exemplary in one not attracting attention to itself. In many ways, this is similar to the approach of the musicians - so completely attuned to Bach's music, you only hear the notes, never them. The notes are detailed and a valuable commentary from Butt himself (no less than 10 pages worth).

Inspirational on every level.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Dunedin ConsortDunedin Consort
J.S. Bach: John Passion, Reconstruction of Bach's Passion LiturgyJ.S. Bach: John Passion, Reconstruction of Bach's Passion Liturgy