Related Reviews
Klassik.com
"Kekke uitvoering; Cappella Nova en MacMillan lijken voor elkaar geboren."
more >>
American Choral Journal
"These performances are outstanding."
more >>
AudioVideoHD
4½ Stars
"Tenebrae es -sin duda- una "experiencia religiosa" muy reconfortante que parte de un trabajo de primer orden."
more >>
Fono Forum
4 Stars
"...beinahe magischen...vorzüglichen."
more >>
Crescendo
"MacMillan a en effet trouvé avec la Capella Nova d'Alan Tavener un interprète idéal, pour qui ce style de musique n'a visiblement aucun secret."
more >>
MusicWeb International
...This work startles by its originality and emotional power.
more >>
Atlanta Audio Society
Another excellent review for Cappella Nova
more >>
Audiophile Audition
4½ Stars
...well worth the attention.
more >>
Klassik.com
4½ Stars
Great review from the German website
more >>
ClassicalMusic.com
Cappella Nova "give exemplary performances of some truly inspiring music".
more >>
High Fidelity Poland
4½ Stars
Great review from the Polish audiophile publication
more >>
AllMusic.com
4½ Stars
"...extraordinary discipline, precision, and passion..."
more >>
Tempo
MacMillan's resourcefulness in writing for singers of differing abilities make him one of today's most valued choral composers.
more >>
International Record Review
these are performances of rare power and intensity
more >>
The Times (Knowledge)
4 Stars
...the beautiful writhing counterpoint reflects contemporary spiritual wrangling...
more >>
The Irish Times
4 Stars
Cappella Nova sing everything here with affecting, communicative directness
more >>
SA-CD.net
5 Stars
Highly enjoyable and probably will not be bettered in the foreseeable future.
more >>
Musical Pointers
Very intense and moving music...recommended.
more >>
The Observer
Marvellous new works...
more >>
Financial Times
4 Stars
...undeniably beautiful...
more >>

James MacMillan - Cappella Nova - Gramophone


01 January 2008
Gramophone
David Fanning

James MacMillan's Strathclyde Motets are aimed at "good church choirs or good amateur choirs", and the seven recorded here hit the mark pretty unerringly, in that the technical means are simple and the expressive ends rich. If I was in that world, I'm sure I would look forward to singing these pieces again and again.

Composed when he was 17, the Missa brevis shows where a significant part of MacMillan's musical personality comes from. Like the recent motets, it blends the archaic and the modern, using modes as the interface (acknowledged models are Kenneth Leighton and Britten) and treading a fine but sure line between the luxurious and the self-denying. The three Tenebrae Responsories - sung by eight core members of Cappella Nova - are made of sterner stuff, but no more so than is appropriate to the darker textual substance.

Listening at a stretch to 70 minutes of this consoling, numinous music arguably goes against its function as conceived, and wall-to-wall a cappella voices (with a highly effective trumpet obbligato from Mark O'Keeffe in the second motet) could easily become too much of good thing. But such is the purity of the singing and the aptness of Greyfriars Kirk acoustic, beautifully captured by Linn's engineering, that the duty of reviewing was never anything but a pleasure.

One of the most attractive features of this disc is the booklet interview between the composer and a member of the choir (whose questions about Gesualdo and Poulenc, among other things, are precisely on target). Done as intelligently by both parties and avoiding self-congratulation, as here, this format is ideal for a CD of new music; just the absence of dates of composition is slightly frustrating.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Cappella NovaCappella Nova
James MacMillan – TenebraeJames MacMillan – Tenebrae