Related Reviews
Fanfare
'In short, a delightful album.'
more >>
Classic FM (South Africa)
4 Stars
"...just relax and be transported to another world."
more >>
Adiemus Fan Magazine
"...it is rare to find an album that has been made by such a genuine and sincere attitude..."
more >>
American Recorder Magazine
"...lighthearted and engaging."
more >>
The Consort
"I highly commend this recording."
more >>
StereoMojo
"...this is one recording that is recommended to try."
more >>
Klassik.com
4 Stars
"...stellen ein feines und zugleich frisches Programm in einer eigenständigen Perspektive vor."
more >>
Fanfare
'Thorby is a thoroughly accomplished player...'
more >>
Toccata
"...seine wahre Pracht ist."
more >>
Atlanta Audio Society
"It's as delightful a way to spend an hour's listening as I know of."
more >>
Opus Musica
"Este trabajo es un placer para los sentidos."
more >>
Hi-Fi Choice
5 Stars
An outstanding review for 'Garden of Early Delights'
more >>
Hi-Fi & Musik
'Hör du till dem som trodde att blockflöjt var enkelt att spela...'
more >>
Crescendo
4 Stars
"L’ensemble du programme baigne dans une séduction certaine faite de maîtrise technique..."
more >>
Gramophone
"This is Paradise indeed."
more >>
Home Theatre Hi-Fi
5 Stars
"...Thorby and Lawrence-King approach their virtuosic repertoire with consummate ease and joyful hearts."
more >>
Scotland on Sunday
4 Stars
"...there's no denying the quality of performance and works themselves."
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
"Thorby's playing exhibits a vitality, exuberance and earthiness..."
more >>
Early Music Review
"These are sparkling and fresh performances..."
more >>
Ultra Audio
"These works are played perfectly by Thorby and Andrew Lawrence-King..."
more >>
Classic FM Magazine
3 Stars
"...pleasant and original...sensitively accompanied."
more >>
High Fidelity
4½ Stars
A fantastic review from the Polish audiophile publication
more >>
The Irish Times
4 Stars
"...sheer joie-de-vivre..."
more >>
Classical Source
"Harp and recorder is an irresistible combination"
more >>
Bay Area Reporter
"...a delight."
more >>
International Record Review
"...a very captivating collection...her execution is flawless..."
more >>
Politiken (translated)
4 Stars
"Go in, close your eyes and let your ears open out: It is refreshingly chirpy, and it is good to listen to at all hours."
more >>
Politiken
4 Stars
"Det er vederkvægende kvidren - og der er nok af det til både tidlig og silde!"
more >>
The Telegraph
"No connoisseur of recorder-playing or Renaissance instrumental virtuosity will want to be without this delightful anthology."
more >>
Diario de Sevilla
"...las más espectaculares disminuciones se combinan con las dulces melodías."
more >>
Manchester Evening News
4 Stars
"The recorder playing is virtuosic in the extreme..."
more >>
The Scotsman
4 Stars
"Freshness and spontaneity light up every moment."
more >>
Financial Times
5 Stars
"...this is music to warm the heart and delight the senses."
more >>
Audiophile Audition
4 Stars
"...she navigates the speediest complex ornamentation with aplomb."
more >>

Garden of Early Delights - Pamela Thorby & Andrew Lawrence-King - MusicWeb-International


26 November 2008
MusicWeb-International
Bob Briggs

This is a delicious disk, full of the most interesting and unusual things. It's a tribute to the two players that such a fascinating and varied recital could be planned for it seems to be quite a miracle that the music has survived for information on many of the composers is so scant. 

Just imagine that you write a great set of madrigals, they're published but in 400 years no-one really knows where or when you were born and died, and were it not for that solitary publication nobody, today, would have heard of you. So it is with some of these composers. I did a little research on each of the composers represented on this disk and the phrase which occurred in almost every source I consulted was "very little is known about his life". 

Despite our lack of knowledge, we do have the music - and what we have here is glorious in its variety, and to make the recital even more interesting there are solo pieces interspersed with the duo works. 

So what of this music? Ortiz was Spanish by birth and there is a real Spanish feel to his music. He published two books of music: Tratado de Glosas in 1553 and Musices liber primus in 1565. The three works in this collection all come from the first book.  

Recercada No.2 is a very jolly dance, requiring some virtuosity on the part of the recorder player, while Recercada segunda de canto Ilano, a stately piece, and Recercada prima sobre doulce mémoire a movement of grave nobility are for psaltry alone. 

Jacob van Eyck was Dutch and, amongst his many accomplishments, he was a virtuoso recorder player. Der Fluyten Lust-hof (The Flute's Garden of Delights, or perhaps, Pleasure Garden) is a collection of pieces - folk songs, dance tunes and contemporary songs - for soprano recorder which rerquire some dexterity from the player. Derde, Doen Daphne d'over is a particularly beautiful lament for the solo instrument, Amarilli Mia Bella is an arrangement for recorder and psaltery of a piece by Giulio Caccini and van Eyck's other two pieces are up-tempo dance numbers.

There are absolutely no biographical details whatsoever about Dario Castello. Did he work at St Mark's in Venice when Monteverdi was maestro di capella? It's thought that he might have died in the great plague of 1630 for he published no music after that date. Only 29 compositions survive and this Sonata Seconda is a very challenging work for the players, written in a variety of contrasting sections.

We probably know about the life of John Dowland than of most of the other composers here, but there are still gaps in our knowledge of him. There is a special melancholy in Dowland's music and the two songs presented here, and played by solo psaltery, are full of that wistfulness.

Johann Schop is a totally new name to me. In 1756 Leopold Mozart made comment on the difficulty of a trill in one of Schop's works! This Lachrime Pavaen is one of the most serious compositions on this disk and it has a depth of feeling which goes far beyond the mere few minutes playing time.

Giovanni Bassano was a cornettist employed from 1576 in various posts at St Mark's, Venice, including, from 1601, conductor of the orchestra. His 1591 he published a collection of ornamented versions of motets and madrigals by leading composers such as Palestrina, Lassus and Rore. His two works heard here are alternately slow and reflective and dance-like - the Divisions on Frais et Gaillard makes a fabulously joyous conclusion to the whole recital.

Giovanni Battista Fontana is known solely for one, posthumous, publication which consists of six sonatas for violin and bass and six more for two violins and bass. A note states that he came from Brescia and worked in various cities in Italy, but that seems to be the sum of our knowledge of him. The Sonatas in this publication contain some of the earliest works in that form, and the bass is more independent than was usual for that time. They are designed to be played by many different combinations and these Sonatas work very well for recorder and chitarrone. The Sonata sesta is a lighter work than its companion, the Sonata Seconda, which contains a particularly striking dance section in the middle. 

Biagio Marini was a virtuoso violinist and his compositions were published and known throughout the European musical world. He traveled throughout his life, and occupied many posts in Europe. It seems that he married three times and had five children. As befits a virtuoso of the violin his works contirbuted to the development of string playing by expanding the repertoire of both solo and accompanied violin and incorporating the slur, double and triple stopping. He used the very first notated tremolando in his music. Sadly none of this is in evidence in his Passacalio which is another stately processional. 

This is a fascinating and most enjoyable recital of music which, under normal circumstances, I would have ignored. It is easy to forget just what a wealth and variety of music was being created during the 150 years before the birth of J S Bach and we are to be grateful to Pamela Thorby, Andrew Lawrence-King and Linn Records for bringing this work to our attention. I am saddened that there is only one solo for the recorder, when there are several for the harp and psaltery but I must not carp, this is a sheer delight. Andrew Lawrence-King's essay in the booklet is fascinating and the recording is bright and clear, but with little reverberation, and an astonishing dynamic range.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Pamela ThorbyPamela Thorby
Garden of Early DelightsGarden of Early Delights