Related Reviews
Spanish Society Quarterly Review
"Beautiful"
more >>
ABC Spain
5 Stars
Another outstanding review for La Guitarra Española
more >>
SA-CD.net
5 Stars
Very highly recommended.
more >>
Goldberg
4 Stars
Great review from the Spanish publication (Spanish)
more >>
AllMusic.com
...nothing less than perfect...
more >>
Hi-Fi & Musik
5 Stars
"Vårdat och kärleksfullt ger han musiken guldkant."
more >>
Gramophone
Gramophone Editor's Choice
more >>
OpusHD.net (French)
5 Stars
Highest commendations from the French website
more >>
The Herald
3 Stars
Baroque music for a summer afternoon, with an intimacy that draws you in.
more >>
MusicWeb-International
Recording of the Month!
more >>
BBCi
This is real summer listening, conjuring up warmer climes than here...
more >>
Atlanta Audio Society
These performances all sound so vital, they successfully avoid the common pall of lifeless "authenticity."
more >>
Early Music Review
His music ranges from simple dance tunes to complex variations requiring considerable dexterity.
more >>
International Record Review
...obtain this disc without delay.
more >>
Classic FM Magazine
A good review for the acclaimed album
more >>
Financial Times
...subtlety and beauty in such perfect proportion.
more >>
The Times
4 Stars
It's a wonderful recital, glistening with jewels from the 18th-century...
more >>
Audiophile Audition
4 Stars
...full of passion and surpassing beauty...
more >>
MusicalPointers.co.uk
Recommended.
more >>
High Fidelity Poland
4½ Stars
Excellent review from the Polish audiophile publication
more >>
The Scotsman
4 Stars
This whole disc is an effusion of passion, flavoured with Mediterranean sunshine.
more >>

Santiago de Murcia - William Carter - Lute News


01 December 2007
Lute News
Monica Hall

Santiago de Murcia has been in the news recently because a new manuscript of his music has come to light in Chile, together with another copy of his printed book Resumen de acompañar. An article in the May issue of Early Music by Alessandro Vera, who discovered the manuscript, sheds fresh light on Murcia's background. It seems that his patron, Jacome Andriani, had trading links with the News World, and that rather than travelling abroad himself, Murcia probably made copies of his music which were send to aficionados overseas.

A new recording of Murcia's music affords a welcome opportunity to explore his contribution to the guitar repertoire. This is a nicely-balanced programme with items from the two ‘Mexican' manuscripts, Passacalles y obras, and Codice Saldívar no. 4 and one piece (or part of a piece!) from the Resumen. Most are sets of variations, a form in which Murcia excels. The three passacalles, each in two sections, are rather sombre although they end with a flurry of scale passages or campanellas. The variations from the Saldívar Codex are more flamboyant, being based on popular dance forms, some of which are African of Mexican in origin. Murcia was fond of Corelli's music and has included arrangements of several movements from the op. 5 violin sonatas in the Passacalles. Two of these are included on the disc. He excelled as an arranger and ranged widely when choosing music to include in his various collections. The Prelude with which Carter introduces the passacalles in D minor forms one curiously chromatic episode in the lengthy Preludio to the suite in that key in Resumen. It is derived from an anonymous keyboard piece included in Martín y Coll's manuscript collection of keyboard music Flores de Música. It would have been nice to have the whole piece! The disc also includes a group of pieces from Sanz's Instrucción de música. Many of Sanz's pieces are simple and very brief, often running to no more than a few bars - the book was intended as an introduction to the guitar at a time when the idea of playing anything other than entirely strummed music may still have been a novelty in Spain. However, more accomplished players would undoubtedly have used such pieces as a basis for elaborate improvisation - which is what Carter has done with flair and originality.

It is refreshing to have most of the music played as solo music, which is surely what Murcia and Sanz intended. I heaved a sigh of relief when I realized that that was to be no percussion ad lib. Carter is to be commended for adhering quite closely to Murcia's own tablature although he can't resist the temptation to add a few flamencoesque touches here and there. He strays from the straight and narrow only by adding a bass line to some of the pieces, played pizzicato on the viola da gamba by his colleague in the Palladian Ensemble, Susanne Heinrich. Although this may not have been quite what Murcia or Sanz had in mind, because the guitar lacks a bass register, the music gains a great deal by being supported in this way especially in the Corelli arrangements and the combination of the two instruments is very attractive. The two players have a field day in Murcia's celebrated ‘Cumbees' with Heinrich keeping a steady 1-2-3 beat in the bass whilst Carter romps away with the hemiola in the guitar part, introducing some unusual dissonance and very Latin sounding rhythms of his own in the strummed passages.

The recording seemed rather over-resonant with a certain amount of fingerboard noise but otherwise this is the most attractive recording of Murcia's music to have come my way for a long time.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

William CarterWilliam Carter
La Guitarra Española - The Music of Santiago de MurciaLa Guitarra Española - The Music of Santiago de Murcia