Related Reviews
iTunes
Named number 8 in: iTunes top 30 classical albums
more >>
The Observer
'Mozart's last four symphonies...have rarely shone as luminously as in these uplifting accounts.'
more >>
The SCOTS Magazine
'...a lasting momento of a tremendous association.'
more >>
allmusic.com
"They have the same drive and verve as his earlier work, but his vision now seems clearer and more radiant than before."
more >>
Audiophilia.com
"...once playing, it is almost impossible to turn off!"
more >>
ResMusica.com
une présentation exceptionnellement belle
more >>
6moons.com
Blue Moon Award: "...Sir Charles Mackerras' vision with the SCO is one of the very finest of the modern era..."
more >>
StereoMojo
Publisher’s Choice Recording: "complete mastery...One can only say bravo."
more >>
The Berkshire Review
"...the greatest interpretation of the Mozart symphonies of our moment..."
more >>
Qantas in-flight magazine
Original passsion and flair...Outstanding.
more >>
Sunday Times
Number 1 Classical Record of 2008
more >>
HMV Choice
Number 1 Classical Record of 2008
more >>
AudioVideoHD
5 Stars
"En definitiva, una auténtica delicia, con una grabación exquisita, característica intrínseca de Linn Records."
more >>
Fanfare
"Magnificent."
more >>
Star Ledger of New Jersey
4 Stars
"...blending period style with modern virtuosity."
more >>
Classica Repertoire
"Nous aimons...beaucoup"
more >>
LiveGuide.com
"These may be the best versions of Symphonies 38 and 39 ever recorded..."
more >>
Crescendo
An "admirable" performance
more >>
Scherzo
'Excepcional' Award from the Spanish publication
more >>
MusicWeb International
Recording of the Month: "...a benchmark of our time."
more >>
Expansion
'Mozart vive!'
more >>
hi-fi +
4½ Stars
Quite brilliant...truly majestic.
more >>
Opus Musica
Disc of the Month
more >>
Early Music Review
...powerful, individual readings.
more >>
Klassik.com
5 Stars
So gelingt gleichsam unter der Hand Mozart-Interpretationen, die man zu den überzeugendsten dieser Sinfonien zählen darf.
more >>
Gramophone
Every bit as good as you would expect. Gramophone Recommended.
more >>
HiFi News
Album of the Month
more >>
The Ticket (Ireland)
4 Stars
simply irresistible
more >>
audiophile.no
5 Stars
Linn Records har spilt inn Mozart sine fire siste symfonier. Til denne oppgaven har de selvfølgelig håndplukket Scottish Chamber Orchestra dirigert av Sir Charles Mackerras.
more >>
The Guardian (Live)
5 Stars
Mackerras's Mozart is full of the life-affirming vitality more often associated with youth
more >>
International Record Review
A vibrant and utterly gripping appearance from first moment to last, and all caught in sound that is amazingly lifelike. No Mozartian should be without these inspiring discs.
more >>
MusicalCriticism.com
4 Stars
"[It] really is as good as it gets."
more >>
McAlister Matheson Music
A recording of "delicacy and spice...grandeur and exuberance"
more >>
Audiophile Audition
4 Stars
some spectacular readings in first class sonics
more >>
The Scotman (Live)
4 Stars
"...power-packed Mozart that has you sitting on the edge of your seat craving more."
more >>
Atlanta Audio Society
...Performances that may well take their place among the best on record.
more >>
The Times
5 Stars
among the very best recordings of these four symphonies on disc
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
Orchestral Disc of the Month: "exhilarating ... ravishing"
more >>
The List
4 Stars
exciting and thrilling
more >>
MusicOMH.com
5 Stars
Anyone who loves classical music has to own this recording...this will be one of the year's finest recordings.
more >>
Independent on Sunday
...Few recordings have the authority and warmth of this release.
more >>
The Observer
Mozart's last four symphonies...have rarely shone as luminously as in these uplifting accounts.
more >>
The Herald
5 Stars
This will have you out of your seat with excitement...a Mozart set to match any.
more >>
The Week
5 Stars
...Astonishing...
more >>
Financial Times
...Sheer vitality...
more >>
BBC Online
This recording should have you stampeding to the record shops.
more >>
Metro
5 Stars
Pure delight.
more >>
SA-CD.net
5 Stars
I can't imagine Mozart being better performed...a wonderful set that will remain long in the memory.
more >>
The Sunday Times
5 Stars
Classical CD of the Week: Possibly their finest record to date...I don't know more enthralling accounts of the G minor and the Jupiter on disc.
more >>
ClassicsTodayFrance.com
4½ Stars
An outstanding review for the orchestral recording
more >>
The Guardian
5 Stars
These are the finest versions of Mozart's greatest symphonies to have appeared on disc in years.
more >>

Mozart Symphonies - SCO & Sir Charles Mackerras - ClassicalSource.com


01 February 2008
ClassicalSource.com
Anthony Hodgson

We know that Mozart was a committed Freemason and in his opera "Die Zauberflöte" (The Magic Flute) he is open about it, the plot being very much a Masonic allegory. Its direct Masonic references would certainly have surprised contemporary audiences and would have been thought daring at the time. This comes to mind because of the outer and inner inlay cards and the booklet cover accompanying this release, which feature an exceptionally fine painting of a Masonic Lodge. A blindfolded candidate is being presented with regalia on display; members of the Lodge stand with drawn swords and Mozart sits on a bench on the edge of the proceedings. His likeness here is very close to that of contemporary portraits and it can safely be assumed that it represents the composer. Mozart's enthusiasm for the craft of Freemasonry apart, however, it is difficult to understand the reason for the allusion but the quality of the colour-printing and the presentation are a credit to Linn. So too the recorded quality, which is admirably clear in all departments of the orchestra yet never oppressively forward. This is very much the sound that I have heard when attending concerts under Sir Charles Mackerras's direction.

The ‘Prague' Symphony is given an exceptionally perceptive interpretation, but first the use of repeats is worth describing. In general, sensible obedience to repeat markings is a strong point in this conductor's interpretations: for example both repeats are made in all finales. This is excellent and clearly Sir Charles agrees with Sir Adrian Boult who felt that performances that did not include these repeats would make these ‘late' symphonies, in his delightful phrase, "something of a tadpole". In the ‘Prague' Symphony, I have never seen a score requiring a second repeat in the first movement (but I have no doubt that there is one). Mackerras takes this repeat making the movement as performed longer than the extensive first movement of Beethoven's ‘Eroica'. However, inclusion of that second repeat seems to hamper the symmetry of the work because only the first part of the succeeding Andante is repeated. I thought Mackerras must be unique in choosing this pattern but I turned to John Eliot Gardiner's superb version of two decades ago, I found that he takes exactly the same view and that there are also notable similarities between the two conductors. True, Gardiner uses period instruments at a slightly lower pitch but his intuitive feeling for balance and his strong, one might almost say Beethovenian, approach is very similar to Mackerras whose ‘modern' instruments convincingly approximate to 18th-century timbres with bright woodwind and clear-cut timpani. In both recordings the onslaught of these instruments at the start of the finale's development is beautifully judged.

The similarity between the two conductors is retained in Symphony 39 (also Gardiner's coupling) but Mackerras is a touch faster. He makes the introduction forcefully dramatic and keeps the tempo of the Allegro flowing firmly throughout the movement. The Andante is not allowed to linger and the Minuet is taken at a sturdy Allegretto, sweeping strongly through the Trio, although some might have wished to hear the second clarinet's delightful bubbling accompaniment more clearly. Incidentally, as in all the minuets, Mackerras takes both repeats after the Trio. The finale benefits from brisk speed and dynamic changes. So often this movement can simply run on cheerfully, but Mackerras retains the sense of drama built up in the previous movements.

The second CD does not entirely achieve the admirable conviction of the first. Mackerras uses Mozart's Revised Version of No.40. My view is slightly coloured by the feeling that every performance I hear using the revision, with its additional clarinets, makes me even more firmly convinced that Mozart should have left the scoring as it was. Barenboim, Beecham, Furtwängler, Eugen Jochum and Marriner, come to mind as those who perform the original and all their readings have something special to say. Further, this Scottish performance of No.40 is somewhat understated. The recording seems slightly more general and the strings do not seem to be sufficiently ‘present' to create the essential sense of urgency in the opening movement. The Molto allegro indication (Allegro molto in some scores) is obeyed well enough but the smoothing effect of the added clarinets and the reserved approach to dynamics leaves a pleasing rather than a dramatic impression. The slow movement moves broadly but with ease and Mackerras observes both repeats, which means that the Andante takes twice as long as its predecessor. The Minuet is controversial - Furtwängler set the standard for this movement 60 years ago by his tense forcefulness and his absolutely strict tempo. The Scottish Chamber Orchestra seems to be playing in a light one-in-a-bar at a tempo arguably much faster than the Allegretto marking implies. Sadly the Trio does not keep up the pace so the last hope of dramatic impact is lost. To slow the pace for this section is particularly disturbing, as is the push-forward at the Minuet's return. In Mackerras's 1976 recording of this work, with the London Philharmonic for Classics for Pleasure, this movement was taken at an unchanged moderate pace. The finale improves matters considerably although it is still not the most dramatic of performances.

The ‘Jupiter' Symphony is another matter. A majestic first movement (including a surprising but effective brief slowing before the first fermata) is followed by an Andante cantabile that flows so elegantly that the slowish tempo is amply justified. The Minuet again raises eyebrows, another ‘fast' Allegretto, which gives a waltz-like lilt to the rhythm. The saving grace is that the Trio stays ‘in tempo' - although a little more from the syncopated horn and trumpet fanfares in the second part of the section would have underlined this urgent feeling even more. In the finale, Mackerras is powerful and dramatic - there is great strength and drive here. The entry into the coda is a gripping moment and the commanding weight of the final pages makes for exciting listening.

I am surprised that when I hear Mackerras recordings the matter of da capo observation keeps cropping up. I find these SCO/Linn versions especially interesting in the light of Mackerras's recordings of several Mozart symphonies from 30 years ago with the LPO. At that time I wrote an adverse criticism of the ‘Jupiter' performance because of the conductor's omission of all repeats in all movements except the Minuet, omissions necessary to fit the symphony onto an LP side. I am therefore delighted to hear the current recording confirming his true realisation of the contours of the music.

Despite my reservations about the G minor Symphony, this new set has a great deal to recommend it and the recording falls most graciously on the ear. The chosen venue has an ideal amount of natural resonance, although in Symphony 40 the orchestra seems slightly less forward, but perhaps there are those who, unlike me, do not crave excitement and tension in this work.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Scottish Chamber OrchestraScottish Chamber Orchestra
Mozart Symphonies 38 - 41Mozart Symphonies 38 - 41