Bach Mass in B Minor - Dunedin Consort - Gramophone
There are few who strive sincerely to juxtapose the bedfellows of academic rigour and inspired musicianship. Given his recent Handelian activity at the helm of the Dunedin Consort and Players, some might have forgotten that John Butt is a Bach research specialist and author of the Cambridge Handbook on the Mass in B minor. In the booklet he explains his thoughts about historically informed performance practice (one voice per part, following the evidence outlined in the writings of Joshua Rifkin and Andrew Parrott), and discusses his choice to make the first recording of Rifkin's recent edition (which reconstructs Bach's score c1749, without later accretions). Butt's interpretation owes firm allegiance to the "OVPP" creed that will not please everyone (even if detractors have not yet produced a single scrap of proof to refute it), but the Dunedin Consort and Players are never perfunctory or merely dogmatic. This performance demands to be heard.
Butt has considered every musical connection, context, texture and form. Not only do the individual movements feel spot-on in articulation and affekt but the free-flowing pacing from one section to the next makes it easy for the listener to be pulled along. Each section of the Roman Ordinary is envisaged as continuous music, so there are no pregnant pauses between solo and choral movements. The first chords of the "Kyrie" are sung boldly by the 10 singers (five "principals" and another five "ripienists"), and the solemn fugue is performed with gentle ardency; every gesture, detail, suspension and arching line is judged and executed with transparency, flexibility and rhetorical potency.
Thomas Hobbs and Matthew Brook sing the principal lower-voice contrapuntal passages with sensitive blend and superb intonation: they also declaim their solo movements with confidence and eloquence. The higher-voiced principals are marginally less successful: the combination of Susan Hamilton and Cecilia Osmond in the duet "Christe eleison" occasionally threatens fragility but perhaps more authoritative and smoother-toned soprano soloists would have been less adaptable in the choruses. Butt's flowing tempo for "Agnus Dei" prevents Margot Oitzinger from conveying the breathtaking timelessness some might hanker after but catharsis is tangible in "Benedictus" (performed movingly by Hobbs and flautist Katy Bircher). The galant character adopted by Butt's elegant harpsichord continuo, Patrick Beaugiraud's poignant oboe and tasteful strings during "Qui sedes" proceeds without pause into "Quoniam"; Anneke Scott's sparky horn playing and Matthew Brook's conversational authority conspire to take no prisoners, and the momentum carries through into a knock-out "Cum Sancto Spiritu".
Once upon a time the bravery of minimal forces tackling this repertoire was ridiculed by sniffy sceptics. Butt and the Dunedins might not change any entrenched minds; but the climax of "Gratias agimus tibi" is as bold, resonant and glorious as anything one would expect (and not always get) from larger forces. The opening of the "Gloria" bursts forth with radiant splendour but also has a dance-like lilt, and with Bach's intricate writing emerges as a compelling dialogue.
The Dunedin Consort's singing conveys the ebb, flow and shading of Bach's choruses with ease and naturalness. The sonorities of full homophonic chords concluding the grandest choruses are thrilling, whereas the densely polyphonic choral passages always possess clarity and logic thanks to the disciplined interplay of the singers. The five principals combine to rapturous effect in "Et incarnatus est", and Butt's handling of the strings and flutes during "Crucifixus" is both patient and emotionally charged.
Many excellent recordings of this monumental work cater for different tastes and priorities. Some have more consistent line-ups of soloists, equally impressive choirs (of varying sizes) and comparably strong artistic direction. Although an excellent one voice-per-part version is nothing new, Butt's insightful direction and scholarship, integrated with the Dunedin's extremely accomplished instrumental playing and consort singing, amount to an enthralling and revelatory collective interpretation of the Mass in B minor - perhaps the most probing since Andrew Parrott's explosive 1985 version (Virgin, 8/86R).