Related Reviews
Herald Scotland
'....the immaculate duo of Gilchrist and Tilbrook lavished their profound emotional and psychological acuity in a shattering account of Schumann's tender, heart-rending vision of a poet's life and love
more >>
MusicWeb International
'he doesn't just sing; he thinks himself vocally into the meaning of the words'
more >>
Opera News
'Gilchrist's humble, deferential singing makes for a lovely, touching rendition'
more >>
BBC Magazine
'an honesty put to the test by the exposed acoustic and a fine artistic imagination are held in a near-perfect equilibrium.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
Recording of the Month: 'A highly desirable disc.'
more >>
American Record Guide
'Gilchrist’s voice is exquisitely lovely in the style of the English choir tenor, and his singing is supremely evocative.'
more >>
Fanfare
'very fine'
more >>
Fanfare
'[Gilchrist] has a real sense of what the songs are about'
more >>
Pizzicato
A review in German
more >>
International Records Review
'a highly intelligent musical performance'
more >>
Klassik
4½ Stars
,,Bei den 'Holy Sonnets of John Donne' beweist die herausragenden Fähigkeiten Gilchrists...was für herrliche Schwebungen auf ‚holy discontent‘, was für eine feine Farbführung, etwa auf ‚crucified‘.''
more >>
Audiophile Audition
4 Stars
'Gilchrist sings wonderfully while pianist Tilbrook is with him every step of the way...This is a terrific production from Linn.'
more >>
The Sunday Times
'Gilchrist is a greatly sensitive interpreter, his tone liquid yet urgent, his diction immaculate and august, his choices admirable.'
more >>
The Guardian
'Gilchrist's rather English sound fits music that was conceived for Pears's equally English style very well, whether in the unbuttoned declarations of love of the Michelangelo songs, or the much darker introspection of the Donne Sonnets.'
more >>

James Gilchrist - My Beloved is Mine - Spirited Magazine


01 September 2013
Spirited Magazine

All the super audio CD releases I've come across from Linn have been of the very highest quality in terms of performances, presentation and sound quality, and this disc is no exception. Featuring James Gilchrist and Anna Tilbrook in three song-cycles and one canticle by Benjamin Britten, everything about the disc emanates thoughtfulness, intelligence and good design. On This Island commences the disc; a song cycle written shortly after the important initial meeting between the precocious young composer and the poet W.H. Auden had taken place, and which sets five of Auden's poems. There is an exhilarating sense of joy in Gilchrist's rendition of the opening Let this florid music praise, and wonderful lyricism in the second stanza, setting a high standard for the rest of the disc: really beautiful singing, a charged and intense atmosphere, and sensitive accompaniment from Tilbrook. Gilchrist's vibrato is quite pronounced, yet I personally don't feel that this detracts at all - slightly on the wide side it may be, yet it is nevertheless perfectly controlled and never excessive. His enunciation is superb throughout. The ensuing Now the Leaves are falling fast is an excellent showpiece for Gilchrist's impressive technical ability (as is Oh, to vex me in the following song cycle, the Holy Sonnets of John Donne), whilst ambience is most perfectly conveyed (for example by slightly growling lower notes which reflect the chilling and sinister atmosphere in Nocturne). At times I wondered whether the balance was spot-on: in Seascape the voice rather battles to be heard over the piano (but perhaps this is intentional?), and in As it is, plenty, I find the piano a little heavy-handed (the jazzy inflections in the voice are good here though). The Holy Sonnets of John Donne (dating from 1945 and setting nine rather dark Sonnets by John Donne) are given robust performances that are full of passion and commitment, and superbly communicated - Since she whom I loved in particular is exceptionally beautiful. The Seven Sonnets of Michelangelo of five years earlier are absolutely radiant (especially Si come nella penna e nell'inchiostro and Veggio co' bei vostri occhi un dolce lume). Gilchrist's Italian pronunciation certainly sounds absolutely convincing to my ear (sometimes a difficulty for English tenors), and I find myself here transported at once to Renaissance Italy. The disc concludes with the first of Britten's five canticles, the eponymous My beloved Is Mine, in a performance that I cannot fault, and that provides an excellent conclusion to the disc. Full texts and translations are provided alongside Gilchrist's own excellent and insightful notes. Very highly recommended indeed.
Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Anna TilbrookAnna Tilbrook
James GilchristJames Gilchrist
My Beloved is MineMy Beloved is Mine