Related Reviews
Fanfare
'Everything on the program is rendered splendidly, as would be expected of this ensemble...Recommended.'
more >>
American Record Guide
'These performances are nothing short of amazing for their unanimity of ensemble, perfectly blended tone, and flawless intonation.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
Recording of the Month: 'Just lovely!'
more >>
Choir & Organ
5 Stars
'This welcome revitalisation of an iconic group is characterised by warmth of tone and beautiful blend. A thoroughly engaging recording of impeccable clarity.'
more >>
Gramophone
'The disc's highlight comes when [Andrew Smith's] setting of Stond wel, Moder under rode follows the anonymous 13th-century setting of the same text, each piece supercharged with the ensemble's raw, intense but poetic style founded on the very basics of vocal communication.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
'Especially striking on this disc are the works by the American Joanne Metcalf and by the Liverpool-born Andrew Smith...The recording is beautifully spaced.'
more >>
MusicWeb International
'A fascinating release.'
more >>
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung
„Es darf als Reverenz an die mittelalterliche Tradition verstanden werden und zugleich an dieses herausragende Ensemble. Wie das Drama der Kreuzigung hier von innen her durchleuchtet wird, im Zusammenklang der klar und transparent geführten Stimmen, ist ergreifend; darin liegt auch ein mystischer Kern."
more >>
El arte de la fuga
'La toma sonora es excelente, diáfana como pocas, ideal para sumergirse en la escucha de estas magníficas composiciones.'
more >>
Financial Times
4 Stars
'The mood throughout is one of serenity and grace.'
more >>

Gothic Voices - Mary Star Of The Sea - Andrew Benson-Wilson


22 August 2016
Andrew Benson-Wilson
Andrew Benson-Wilson

Joanne Metcalf: Il nome del bel fior; Andrew Smith: Stond wel, Moder, under rode; and pieces by Godric of Finchale, Leonel Power, Dunstaple, Richard Smert, and Anonymous.

This beautiful recording contrasts music by contemporary composers Joanne Metcalf and Andrew Smith with 12th to 15th century settings of Marian texts, many of them anonymous.

The first part explores the mythical and spiritual qualities of Mary, with three extracts from Joanne Metcalf's Il nome del bel fior (a ten-part setting of extracts from Dante's Paradiso) together with her Music for the star of the sea. The opening track is particularly beautiful, with Catherine King singing Joanne Metcalf's haunting meditation on the single word ‘Maria'. The earlier pieces reflect the different musical styles that were developing during the 13th and 14th centuries.

The second part focuses on the more human aspects of Mary, notably with the thirteenth-century setting of the Middle English poem Stond wel, Moder, under rode(c1250) and its dialogue between Mary and Jesus. Andrew Smith's setting of the same sequence of verses, with its tightly wrought four-part harmonies, form a contemporary reflection on Mary as the mother of Jesus. It is divided into two parts, the second being more intense than the first. Also included is one of ‘Godric's Hymns', Kyrie / Crist and Sainte Marie, the earliest known English-language text to survive with its melody, written during ‘Saint' Godric's 60 years sojourn as a hermit in Finchale, Durham.

The recording concludes with a Gregorian chant setting of Gaude, Maria virgo and the powerful anonymous 13th century rondellusAlleluia psallat / Alleluia concinat / Virga Jesse, the three voices of the conductus bouncing along merrily while, in a nice reflection of the opening track, the intervening plainchant verse is sung by the solo voice of Catherine King.

The music of the two contemporary composers was particularly well chosen, both adopting and varying a recognisably mediaeval musical style without in any way approaching pastiche. The four singers of Gothic Voices (Catherine King mezzo-soprano, Steven Harrold tenor, Julian Podger tenor, and Stephen Charlesworth baritone) produce an exceptionally good consort sound as well as impressing in their various solo roles. I particularly liked the presence of Catherine King's gently sophisticated mezzo voice on top of the consort rather than the more usual male countertenor voice.

Whether or not you have any religious interest in the biblical figure of Mary, the music and the texts of these pieces might help to explain Mary's importance in the mediaeval mind. 


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Catherine KingCatherine King
Gothic VoicesGothic Voices
Mary Star Of The SeaMary Star Of The Sea