Related Reviews
Fono Forum
4 Stars
'This succeeds because Pinnock has worked out the characteristics of every single piece...'
more >>
Sid’s Classical Reviews
5 Stars
'A fabulous recital.'
more >>
Financial Times
4 Stars
'As the disc's centrepiece, Bach's French Suite No. 6 in E major exudes authority - nothing flash or rushed, just the wisdom of maturity.'
more >>
All Music
4½ Stars
'Pinnock has chosen well from representative pieces, and the album is enjoyable for the variety and richness of these composers' approaches.'
more >>
BBC Music Magazine
5 Stars
Instrumental Choice: 'I can recommend this birthday disc with wholehearted enthusiasm.'
more >>
Early Music Review
5 Stars
'The youthful sparkle might not be so visible in Matthias Tarn's recent photo of Pinnock in the CD booklet, but there is no dimming in the exuberance of his playing.'
more >>
Planet Hugill Blog
4 Stars
'Pinnock brings remarkable range of colours to the music and never fails to engage.'
more >>
Gramophone
'His is the fast-fingered but also beautifully controlled touch of a true harpsichordist, producing a rich sprung tone, exquisitely turned ornaments that seem to be both nimble and unhurried at the same time, and (as the flowing lines of the Bach best reveal) faultless legato.'
more >>
The Observer
4 Stars
'...Pinnock has assembled a quirky and intensely personal collection...'
more >>
Kevin Bryan's Record Reviews
'...Pinnock's consumate keyboard artistry breathes new life into them all.'
more >>

Trevor Pinnock - Journey - MusicWeb International


18 April 2016
MusicWeb International
Brian Wilson

The journey in the title is twofold: inspired by the travels of Antonio Cabezón, the sixteenth-century organist and composer whose variations on a popular tune open the programme, Trevor Pinnock weaves a path not only through Cabezón's life but also through his own enviable career.  Cabezón and Domenico Scarlatti bookend the album - from a Spanish composer who travelled, to an Italian who settled in Spain - with Sweelinck's Variations on Mein junges Leben hat ein End at its heart.  Cabezón's journey was matched by a much shorter one for the young Pinnock, to the house of pianist Ronald Smith and eventually to his being tutored there by Smith's sister, June.  Being born in Canterbury certainly had its advantages.

I have already alluded to the Sweelinck in my recent review of the Glossa 6-CD set of that composer's complete keyboard music.  As I noted there, it's six of one and half-a-dozen of the other in terms of performance.  Pieter Dirksen on Glossa has the considerable advantage of our having heard the tune on which the variations are based immediately before his performance, something which would hardly have been feasible for Linn.  Pinnock also plays the work noticeably faster but the chosen tempi suit the different instruments: Dirksen on the more intimate virginal, Pinnock on the harpsichord. 

Of necessity only one instrument is used throughout the programme but it suits the very wide chronological range of the music very well, with appropriate registration for the earlier music.  Re-tuning would have been required at some stage: the earlier pieces are played in meantone temperament and there's a variety of unequal temperaments for the rest of the programme.

It would be pointless to compare the performances with those on other recordings: there's no comparable programme and, even if there were, many would want to have this SACD as a celebration of Pinnock's 70th birthday.  Maybe the Sweelinck work is significant in that we septuagenarians cannot refer to our junges Leben anymore, but I hope that it's not the end of his journey - or mine.  I need hardly say that the playing is as brilliant as ever it was: you would hardly know that much of what we hear is technically very difficult and all the performances are well suited to the tone of the music.  The photographs on pages 8 and 14 show a much older Trevor Pinnock than of yore but the first reminds us of his thoughtful approach to the music - try the Bach - and the second of the sheer joie de vivre that his playing can still evoke, as in the Scarlatti works which close the recital. 

Trevor Pinnock refers in the notes to his friendship with Rafael Puyana and, while I'm sure that his instrument is not the kind of monster that Puyana used to play, his performance of the Scarlatti reminds me of the sheer abandon of the latter's playing without its excesses.

The recording is very good, as heard from the stereo SACD layer, and the notes are excellent.  As usual from me, a short review betokens a strong recommendation.


Bookmark and Share


Related Links

Trevor PinnockTrevor Pinnock
JourneyJourney